Product Failure 11: Brand/Company mismatch

When companies try to expand their market, they need to make sure that I align to the brand values or general message. Sometimes we could find a mismatch that leaded to the end of the product.


Geber singles 1974-1976

Gember was leading the market of baby’s food and their core message was “Babies are our business, our only business”. However, after the baby boom the number of new-borns went down and they feared their business will decline. Therefore, they decided to expand their product lines and started selling peanut butter and ketchup. However, their most risky mode was the Singles, which were adult meals with the slogan “We were good for you in the past, and now” [1]. However, the clients didn’t feel like eating from a pot like a baby, they even had the same name with the surname “single”! It didn’t matter that the food was sweet and sour pork or burgundy beef, they didn’t want to feel like a baby.

Image result for gerber singles

Satisfries 2013-2014

Burger King decided to launch a healthier version of their fries, with less calories so they could attract the people that were looking for healthier alternatives. However, the consumers weren’t interested enough to keep them in the market and they Burger King discontinued them. Experts explained that those that want fast food is in part, due to wanting to indulge themselves, which doesn’t fit with healthy food. It is quite “a coincidence” that right after announcing the end of the Satisfries, Burger King announced the come back of the Chicken Fries [2], [3].

Image result for satisfries

Zima 1993-2008

It was an alcoholic drink launched in 1993 and discontinued after 15 years after a continuous trial and error trying to reach their desired audience: men. From the beginning all the campaigns seek to attract the masculine audience but, the drink became popular among ladies which caused that their target audience to distance even further from the drink. The sales in the 1994 were 1.3 million barrels, but once it was associated with femininity (1996) the sales dropped to 403.000 [4].

Image result for zima

Arch Deluxe 1996-2000

Launched in 1996 was designed to attract the “adult” sophisticated public to McDonalds. These is far from the core values of the company: friendliness for the whole family and product consistency. The clients know what to order and they know what to expect in terms of flavours and quality [5]. A new version of this product was launched in the USA in 2018 [6].

Image result for arch deluxe 1996

Life Savers Soda 1980

Life Savers were a candy company founded in 1912 that offered a summer candy that wouldn’t melt with the heat. In the 80s the company decided to launch a drink with the same name. Even though the market tests were positive, the soda wasn’t welcome because parents thought of it as liquid candy [7].

Image result for life savers soda

Colgate Kitchen Entrees 1982

In 1982, Colgate decided to launch a series of premade frozen dishes. The problem, as you can imagine, is that the brand was associated with dental hygiene since its foundation in 1817. In terms of flavour you could mostly associate it to fresh or peppermint, which is completely opposite to the meals they offered such as lasagne or meatballs [8].

Image result for colgate kitchen entrees

Bic Panties.

Bic decided to launch their new line of pantyhose for ladies in 1976. It was normal for offices to order pens and paper to Bic, so why not the panties? This way if any of the panties of the ladies of the office broke the ladies could immediately change, keeping the company image intact. The idea was discarded after a year because ladies associated Bic with use and dispose products or low quality products. At the same time, even if they knew that panties are usually made of plastic, they didn’t want to associate them with a company that makes plastic goods.

Image result for bic pantyhose

[1] M. Moskowitz, “Babies No Longer Enough For Geber,” La Crosse Tribune. p. 11, 1974.
[2] L. Stampler, “Burger King to Phase Out Its Lower-Cal Satisfries | Time,” Time. 2014.
[3] M. C. White, “French Fry Fail: Most Burger Kings to Drop ‘Satisfries,’” NBC News. 2014.
[4] B. Koerner, “The long, slow, torturous death of Zima.,” Slate. 2008.
[5] M. Haig, Brand Failures: The Truth About the 100 Biggest Branding Mistakes of All Time, Kogan Page. 2003.
[6] K. Taylor, “McDonald’s tests Archburger after ’90s flop - Business Insider,” Business Insider. 2018.
[7] J. Rath, “Failed soda brands - Business Insider,” Business Insider. 2017.
[8] A. Eborn, “The Failure Awards for defunct branding | #1 Colgate Beef Lasagne | The Drum,” TheDrum. 2017.

 

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to top